Antony Gormley’s ‘phallic’ statue may damage our reputation, say students

Antony Gormley’s ‘phallic’ statue may damage our reputation, say students

Imperial College Union motion says students should have been consulted on work, due to ‘obvious’ erect penis interpretation

DIagram of sculpture

University students at Imperial College London are battling to prevent the installation of new sculpture by Antony Gormley over concerns that the work is “phallic”.

Alert, a six-metre-high stack of cantilevered steel blocks meant to resemble a squatting human figure, is scheduled to be installed in the university’s newly built Dangoor Plaza in South Kensington this summer.

According to Gormley, the sculpture represents a figure “balancing on the balls of the feet while squatting on its haunches”.

But a motion released by the Imperial College Union says the sculpture may “hurt the image and reputation of the college” because of its “obvious” interpretation as a person baring their erect penis.

Under this interpretation, the motion adds, the phallus extends “approximately three metres horizontally”, about half the total height of the artwork.

Diagram of sculpture showing two interpretations

“While the artist’s intended form may ‘[evoke our] community of scientific research’ the phallic interpretation does not. The name Alert could also be understood as referring to the statue’s phallus being erect,” the union said.

They also claim students were not consulted about the installation, which will serve as a centrepiece of an area used by students, staff and the public. They note that while there is “nothing inherently wrong with phallic imagery in art”, the phallic interpretation’s preoccupation with the penis could be considered inappropriate for a grand public display.

One of the key concerns for the union was the “exclusionary” phallic interpretation, when scientific research has been beset with issues around gender ratio and inclusion. Official university statistics show that only 41.8% of the full-time students at Imperial College were female in the 2020-2021 academic year.

“College publicity regarding the statue chose an angle that avoided making the statue appear phallic,” the motion added. “This suggests that this interpretation, and backlash, was not unforeseen by some individuals within the college”.

Artist’s impression of sculpture in position

The sculpture was given to Imperial College by the alumnus Brahmal Vasudevan and his wife, Shanthi Kandiah.

In a statement about the work on the university’s website, Gormley said he wanted to explore the correlation between people and their environment.

“Through the conversion of anatomy into an architectural construction I want to reassess the relation between body and space,” he said. “Balancing on the balls of the feet while squatting on its haunches and surveying the world around it the attitude of the sculpture is alive, alert and awake.”

Vasudevan said he shared the College’s “vision for a vibrant public space” and was “proud to bring this iconic, world-class piece of art” to the heart of campus.

Sign up to First Edition, our free daily newsletter – every weekday morning at 7am BST

Speaking to the Art Newspaper, the research postgraduate at the university who submitted the motion said he doubted it would affect the installation of the sculpture. “I think that this is not the sort of thing that the college would pull out of or listen to students about,” he said.

Gormley, whose previous works include the Angel of the North in Gateshead and Another Place on Crosby Beach near Liverpool, won the Turner prize in 1994 and is one of Britain’s leading sculptors.

But this is not the first time his work has courted controversy: last year, his sculptures in the seaside town of Aldeburgh, entitled Quartet (Sleeping), were found to violate local planning laws and were likened by local residents to “sex toys”.

An Imperial College London spokesperson said: “Sir Antony Gormley is one of the world’s foremost living artists, and we are grateful to have been gifted one of his iconic sculptures.”